American Made Easter Candy Brands We Love

Rainbow color marshmallow peeps and jelly beans.

With whole aisles dedicated to Easter candy in stores today, it is quite overwhelming when one is looking for American made candy to purchase. Reading the labels isn’t always helpful, as many packages don’t even state where the candy is made. Well, USA Love List has done the research so you don’t have to, and we’ve compiled this list of our favorite American made Easter candy options.  Whether you are on the hunt for GMO free, natural candy, or you prefer classic Easter candy favorites  in your Easter basket, this list has the info you need to buy American.

Be sure to check out our USA Love List Candy Made in the USA Ultimate Source List for more American made favorites!

American Made Easter Candy Options

Easter egg hunt candy- Spring Caramel Creams
Goetze’s Candy Company has been making candy in the USA since 1895. Caramel Creams, and Mini Cow Tales both fit perfectly in plastic eggs. They are nut free and make a great addition to any Easter egg hunt.


Organic candy |Made in USA | GMO free Easter candy
Easter Bunny is always on the hunt for American made individually wrapped candies to stuff into plastic eggs for egg hunts. TruJoy Sweets organic fruit chews are GMO free and contain no artificial colors or flavorings.

Toostsie Roll Easter candy | Made in USA

Easter Bunny has been delivering American made Tootsie Roll chewy candy to kiddos for over 100 years.
Jelly Belly jelly beans | Made in USA Easter candy
Jelly Belly gourmet jelly beans mini packs fit perfectly into plastic eggs.
Organic candy | GMO free candy | Made in USA
Surf Sweets Spring Mix Jelly Beans are GMO free, certified organic, and made with no high fructose corn syrup.  Surf Sweets jelly beans are made in a nut free facility.
Teenee Beanee jelly beans | Made in USA Easter candy
Teenee Beanee  jelly beans are miniature version of classic jelly beans. They are made in Pennsylvania by Just Born Co.  
UNREAL candy coated milk chocolate #madeinUSA #GMOfree #Soyfree #madeinUSA #EasterCandy
UNREAL candy coated milk chocolates are GMO fee, gluten free, and 100% real. Natural, plant based ingredients are used for the candy coloring, not chemical dyes.
justin's nut butter candy | Made in USA | organic Easter candy
Justin’s Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups are GMO free and certified organic.
Palmer Easter candy: Made in USA
The R.M Palmer Company has been manufacturing novelty chocolate candy in the US for over 60 years.
Mini Cow Tales Easter basket treats

MMM…caramel! American made Cow Tales and Mini Cow Tales chewy caramel sticks with a cream center, are a tasty addition to any Easter basket. Cow Tales are nut free, and are available in Strawberry, Chocolate, Original/Vanilla, and Caramel Apple flavors
Surf Sweets candy | Organic, GMO free Easter candy
From Gummy Bears, to Gummy Worms and fruit flavored gummy rings, Surf Sweets has the fruit juice based gummy candy for your children’s Easter baskets.  All Surf Sweets gummy treats are naturally sweetened, GMO free, and organic.
Chocolate covered Peeps | Made in USA | Easter basket treats
Yes, now the classic marshmallow Peeps are available covered in chocolate! Peeps treats are made in Pennsylvania by Just Born Co.  Peeps chicks and bunnies are available in a variety of colors.

Brachs marshmallow eggs | Made in USA Easter candy

Easter Bunny used to deliver Brach’s Bunny Basket Marshmallow Eggs to my house when I was little! It’s great to see that they are still made in the USA!



Easter candy that we love | made in USA


Disclosure: This is a sponsored post which USA Love List is proud to share with you because, sponsored or not, we only share stuff we love.

Follow USA Love List’s board Easter on Pinterest.

About The Author

Post by Tracey Hanson

Tracey Hanson is the USA Love List Green/Family Living Editor. Follow her on Twitter and Pinterest


  1. Don’t forget to shop locally! In Massachusetts? Tons of great Easter goodies at Putnam Pantry in Danvers! Home made chocolate fudge, chocolate eggs and chocolate bunnies!

  2. The best Easter candy ever… made in Pennsylvania: Gardner’s Candies Peanut Butter Meltaway Eggs! My mom has been giving them to us since we were kids, and hasn’t ever missed a year, even if it means shipping them overseas….

  3. Sheena Myers says:

    Thank you! Thank you! Thank you! for giving us a list of Easter candy made in the USA! Now I don’t have to flip every candy bag in the store looking for those 4 awesome words! 😀

  4. Trudy Miner says:

    Palmer chocolate tastes great! I’ve eaten it for years!

  5. Love that not only are some of the options USA made, but also nut free!!

  6. Brittany Thomas says:

    Love this post! I love finding new brands and I love that you share the made in USA ones. Bonus points for the few that are organic as well!

  7. Michele P says:

    I love most of these brands, some I haven’t tried yet but will be looking for in the stores. Many I have had for years due to their quality and the fact that they are candy made right here in the USA, plus my mom won’t eat anything that is made elsewhere for sweets etc…

  8. @MomLuvsSPORTZ says:

    Great blog about candies MADE IN THE USA! Love them all!

  9. ellen beck says:

    I like how many are able to be found in ‘chain’ stores too. I have tried quite a few of them, but good old Peeps screams Easter and always will. Good to see how many there are!

  10. If you want to avoid gelatin/dairy/animal products, Sweet & Sara makes adorable and super-delicious vegan marshmallow treats in Long Island City, Queens, NY.

  11. Lauryn R says:

    I love all of these Classic Easter candies! The Cadbury egg used to be my favorite until they changed the recipe.

Something to Say?


Include my latest blog post.